FCA thematic and multi-firm reviews: what happens when your firm is selected

Key points

  • Multi-firm work is how the FCA builds an evidence base across a portfolio before publishing expectations that apply to every firm in it.
  • Selection is not an allegation. It usually reflects business model, size, growth rate or an outlier position in reported data.
  • The information request is the review. What a firm can produce quickly, and how internally consistent it is, shapes the supervisory impression more than the covering narrative.
  • Published findings apply to the whole portfolio. Firms not selected are expected to self-assess against them and to be able to evidence that they did.
  • Good practice examples in published findings become the de facto benchmark used in later supervisory contact.
On this page

A multi-firm review is an FCA examination of a sample of firms on one theme, followed by published findings that apply to every similar firm. Thematic and multi-firm reviews are the FCA's main tool for setting expectations at scale. A sample of firms is examined in depth, findings are published, and the whole portfolio is then expected to have read, assessed and acted. Understanding the mechanics changes how a firm responds, whether or not it is in the sample.

How the process works

Scoping. The FCA identifies a harm or a theme, often from supervisory intelligence, complaints data, regulatory returns or previous thematic work.

Sample selection. Firms are selected to give a representative view of the portfolio. Selection criteria typically include size, business model, growth rate, distribution model and position relative to portfolio averages in reported data.

Information request. Selected firms receive a detailed request with a deadline. Some requests are informal and some are formal notices under section 165 FSMA, which the firm must comply with.

Deep dives. Some firms receive follow-up interviews, systems demonstrations or file reviews.

Individual feedback. Selected firms typically receive firm-specific feedback, which may include required actions.

Publication. The FCA publishes aggregated findings on its website, usually with examples of good and poor practice. Planned reviews are often signalled in the FCA's annual Regulatory Priorities reports, which replaced portfolio letters in 2026.

What the information request actually tests

The content of the answers matters. So does everything around them.

What is requestedWhat it reveals
Policies and proceduresWhether the framework is current, owned and version controlled
Management informationWhether the board sees data capable of supporting a decision
Monitoring outputWhether controls are tested, and whether failures are recorded honestly
Customer or transaction samplesWhether the practice matches the policy
Governance minutesWhether challenge occurs and is recorded

The speed and consistency of production also carry signal. A firm that takes six weeks to assemble basic control evidence has told supervision something about its data architecture before a single answer is read.

Practical steps for a selected firm

Read the request against the rulebook. Identify which obligation each question maps to. Answers that address the question but not the obligation invite follow-up.

Sample your own files first. Test the sample the FCA will see. Where a file is deficient, say so, explain the root cause and set out the remediation. Volunteered issues with a plan are treated differently from issues discovered by the reviewer.

Maintain internal consistency. Numbers given in the response must reconcile to regulatory returns and to board MI. Unexplained variances become their own line of enquiry.

Do not overstate. Describing a control as embedded when it was implemented last quarter is the single most common credibility failure.

Brief the board. Selection should be reported to the board with the response and any subsequent feedback.

What firms not selected must do

Published findings are directed at the whole portfolio. The expected response is a self-assessment against each finding and each good practice example, recorded in writing, considered by the board, and converted into actions where gaps exist.

This is the same discipline as responding to a Dear CEO letter, and our guidance on responding to a Dear CEO letter sets out the structure. The self-assessment is the document supervision will ask for if the theme resurfaces at the firm.

Turning findings into evidence

A finding is closed when three things exist: a control change that addresses the root cause, monitoring that tests the changed control, and a re-test result showing the control operating. Anything short of that is an action item, not a closure.

Firms that run this discipline consistently build something valuable: a documented record of self-identification and correction, which is the strongest possible position going into any future supervisory contact. Our guidance on regulatory health checks covers how to run that assessment proactively.

This article is general information as at 19 October 2026 and is not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

What is an FCA multi-firm review?

It is a supervisory exercise in which the FCA examines a sample of firms within a portfolio against a defined theme, provides firm-specific feedback, and publishes aggregated findings that set expectations for the whole portfolio.

Why was my firm selected for a thematic review?

Selection usually reflects business model, size, growth rate, distribution arrangements or an outlier position in reported data. It is not in itself an allegation of failure.

How long do firms have to respond to a multi-firm information request?

Each request sets its own deadline, and deadlines are often short, which is why the ability to produce control evidence quickly matters as much as the content of the response.

Do published thematic findings apply to firms not in the sample?

Yes. The FCA expects every firm in the portfolio to self-assess against the findings and good practice examples, to act on any gaps, and to be able to evidence that it did so.

How should a firm evidence that a thematic finding is closed?

By showing a control change that addresses the root cause, a monitoring test of the changed control, and a re-test result demonstrating that the control is operating effectively.

Is a multi-firm review request compulsory?

It depends on the request. Some are informal, although Principle 11 still expects open cooperation. Others are formal notices under section 165 FSMA, which the firm must comply with.

Where does the FCA publish multi-firm review findings?

On its website, as multi-firm review publications. Planned work is often signalled in the sector Regulatory Priorities reports published each year.

Related