An authorised debt collector is answerable to the FCA for how it collects, whoever owns the debt. On 5 November 2026 the FCA said Ethica Resolve Limited, an authorised firm collecting for West 28th Street Limited, an owner that is not FCA regulated, had agreed restrictions after demanding repayment of loans made under disguised remuneration schemes. Ethica will tell affected consumers they have no enforceable obligation to pay at this stage, will make no further demands in the proposed court claim while the legal issues are resolved, and, with the owner, will not seek default judgments. The case shows how the FCA applies the Consumer Credit sourcebook (CONC) to disputed debts, and what collectors acting for unregulated owners should check before taking instructions.
What happened
Disguised remuneration schemes paid people, often contractors, consultants and agency workers, through loans instead of salaries. West 28th Street Limited bought such loans, or purported loans, from a third party and instructed Ethica to collect them. Many borrowers dispute that they owe the amounts claimed and whether the debts can be enforced at all.
| Requirement agreed with the FCA | Effect |
|---|---|
| Write to affected consumers | Explaining they have no enforceable obligation to pay at this stage |
| No further demands | In the current proposed court claim, while regulatory and legal issues are resolved |
| No default judgments | Ethica and West 28 will not ask a court for judgment against someone who has not responded |
| Vulnerable consumers | Additional protections, with Ethica identifying consumers who may be vulnerable |
The FCA said it has not been decided whether the debts can be enforced, which may be for a court, and that consumers should not ignore formal court documents.
The CONC rules that apply to disputed debts
| Rule | What it requires |
|---|---|
| CONC 7.5.3R | Do not ignore or disregard a claim that a debt is settled or disputed, and do not keep demanding payment without clear justification or evidence that the claim is not valid |
| CONC 7.14.2G | Valid grounds for dispute include that the person is not the borrower, the debt does not exist, or the amount is wrong |
| CONC 7.14.3R | Where a customer disputes a debt on valid grounds, or what may be valid grounds, investigate and give details of the debt in a timely manner |
| CONC 7.14.4R | Where identity or the amount is disputed, it is for the firm, not the customer, to establish it |
| CONC 7.14.6R | A collector that is not the lender or owner must pass the customer's information to the owner, or report the outcome if it has authority to investigate |
| CONC 7.5.4R | A collector must refer a reasonable instalment offer to the owner unless it has authority to accept it |
What collectors acting for unregulated owners should check
- Title and enforceability. Before collecting, obtain evidence of the owner's title, the original agreements and a legal view on enforceability where the debt type is contested.
- Dispute handling. Agree in writing that disputed accounts are paused, investigated and evidenced under CONC 7.14, and that the owner cannot direct otherwise.
- Litigation. Agree when court action may be taken, and do not seek default judgments on accounts the collector knows are disputed.
- Vulnerability. Apply the firm's own vulnerability policy, whatever the owner's approach.
- Communications. Review letters for statements about liability, enforcement or consequences that the evidence does not support.
- Consumer Duty. Apply the Duty's outcomes to the collector's own activities, including avoiding foreseeable harm.
A collector cannot outsource its regulatory obligations to its client. If the owner's instructions conflict with CONC, the collector has to decline or change them.
How Regulatory Counsel helps
We advise debt collection, debt purchase and credit firms on CONC, collections file reviews, owner and client due diligence, and Consumer Duty evidence. See our guide to CONC, affordability and forbearance, our consumer credit compliance audit guide and our consumer credit sector page.