The FCA proposes to let workplace pension providers exclude certain performance fees from the 0.75% charge cap on default funds, in CP26/40 published on 12 November 2026. A fee would qualify only if it is calculated solely by reference to investment performance and if minimum terms were agreed with the manager when the investment was made. The exemption would be optional and would come with safeguards on information sharing, fair allocation between savers and due diligence on how private assets are valued. Responses are due by 14 January 2027, and the FCA expects to make final rules in summer 2027.
This guide sets out what the charge cap does now, what CP26/40 proposes, and what providers and Independent Governance Committees (IGCs) should prepare.
The charge cap today
The charge cap was introduced in 2015. It limits administration charges in the default arrangement of a qualifying workplace pension scheme to 0.75% a year of funds under management. In contract-based schemes regulated by the FCA, performance fees currently count towards the cap. In trust-based schemes, certain performance fees have been excluded from the cap since 2023, under government changes with protections for members.
Performance fees are common in private equity, venture capital and private credit, where managers are paid a share of gains above a hurdle. Counting them inside a 0.75% cap makes it hard for contract-based default funds to hold these assets, even where they could improve long-term returns.
What CP26/40 proposes
| Proposal | Detail |
|---|---|
| Qualifying fees | Fees calculated solely by reference to increases in investment performance, judged on substance, including carried interest arrangements not formally called performance fees |
| Pre-agreed terms | A minimum set of terms agreed between provider and manager when the investment is made, covering how fees are calculated, when they are paid, and how short-term fluctuations are handled |
| Funds the provider cannot negotiate | The provider must confirm the required terms are in place before investing; otherwise the fees stay inside the cap |
| Transparency | A new information sharing term, so providers and IGCs get what they need to assess value and fairness, plus disclosure to members drawn from the trust-based statutory guidance |
| Fairness between savers | Providers work with managers so fees are allocated fairly between savers, relying on the Consumer Duty's fair value requirements |
| Valuation | Due diligence on managers' valuation governance. If appropriate policies and procedures cannot be established, the provider must not proceed with the investment |
| Physical assets | An exemption from the cap for physical asset costs, largely mirroring the trust-based rules except for the cost of valuing an asset |
| Optional | Providers may use the exemption, but only where it is in savers' interests and they can meet the protections |
The FCA is clear that greater flexibility is not a licence to charge more: any higher charges must be justified by additional value to savers.
Why now
The proposals align the contract-based regime with trust-based schemes. Under the Mansion House Accord of May 2025, 17 major UK pension providers named alignment on the charge cap as a "critical enabler" for their voluntary commitments to invest in private assets. The FCA will share the consultation evidence with the Department for Work and Pensions, which will consider any changes to the trust-based side case by case.
What it means for providers and IGCs
Providers that want to use the exemption will need investment governance able to show the decision is in savers' interests: a view on expected net returns after performance fees, the pre-agreed terms with each manager, valuation due diligence, and fair allocation between members who join and leave at different times. Value for money assessments and the Consumer Duty fair value assessment should reflect the higher potential costs.
IGCs already must consider costs and charges, including those exempt from the cap. Under the proposals they would need access to performance fee methodologies and data to judge whether the fees offer value. IGC terms of reference and information requests to providers should be updated in time for the first assessments after the rules take effect.
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 2015 | Charge cap of 0.75% introduced |
| 2023 | Certain performance fees excluded from the cap for trust-based schemes |
| May 2025 | Mansion House Accord |
| 12 November 2026 | CP26/40 published |
| 14 January 2027 | Consultation closes |
| Summer 2027 | FCA expects to make final rules |
What to do now
- Decide whether a private markets allocation in the default fund is likely within the next three years.
- If so, respond to CP26/40 on the definition, the pre-agreed terms and the valuation requirements.
- Map existing and planned private market funds against the proposed pre-agreed terms.
- Brief the IGC and agree the information it will need.
- Build performance fees into value for money and fair value work now, so the evidence exists when the rules take effect.
Our guides to Consumer Duty for investment and wealth firms and the FCA's Guided Retirement proposals cover related obligations for pension providers.
How Regulatory Counsel helps
We help pension providers and their IGCs respond to consultations, build investment governance and value for money evidence, and apply the Consumer Duty to pension products. See our investment and wealth firms sector page.