FCA pure protection market study final report (MS24/1.5)

Key points

  • The FCA published its pure protection market study final report on 21 September 2026 and found competition generally works well for policyholders.
  • 58% of people hold no protection, and 59% of them have never considered it. The FCA will tackle this gap without new rules, expecting progress within 12 to 18 months.
  • Loaded premiums are not banned: at current levels they are not leading to poor pricing outcomes, but firms must show fair value under PROD 4.
  • Unnecessary switching affects around 19,000 customers a year; the FCA will act against individual firms rather than intervene market-wide.
  • Distributors should strengthen fair value evidence on remuneration, monitor switching and record protection discussions at life events.
On this page

The FCA published the final report of its pure protection market study (MS24/1.5) on 21 September 2026. It found that competition in protection distribution generally works well for people who hold cover: claims acceptance is high and insurers generally pay out more than 50% of premiums in claims. It will not introduce new rules. Instead it will tackle the "protection gap" (58% of people hold no protection, and 59% of them have never considered it) through FCA, industry and stakeholder action, and it expects meaningful progress within 12 to 18 months. For advisers and brokers the practical message is about evidence: fair value assessments, remuneration and switching will be tested through supervision under the Consumer Duty and PROD 4, not through new market-wide rules.

This guide sets out what the FCA found, what it decided not to do, and what protection advisers, mortgage brokers who sell protection and protection insurers should do now.

What the FCA found

AreaFinding
Competition for policyholdersGenerally works well: wide product range, high claims acceptance, claims generally over 50% of premiums, stable new business premiums
The protection gap58% of people hold no protection product; 59% of those have never considered their protection needs
Who is most affectedPeople with pre-existing or complex medical conditions, renters, lower-income households, the self-employed and gig workers
Sales processLong, complicated journeys, slow medical evidence, unclear communications and limited products for complex needs cause people to abandon purchases
Regulatory uncertaintySome firms said they are unclear whether the rules allow innovation in product design and distribution
Smaller issuesLimited in scale and not systemic: some incentives to switch customers unnecessarily, and requests for clarity on adjusting premiums for commission

What the FCA decided not to do

IssueThe FCA's decision
Loaded premiums (insurer funds extra commission by raising the premium)At current levels they are not leading to poor pricing outcomes; no ban. Every firm must still show fair value under PROD 4
Restricted panelsCommission is higher on average than whole of market, but premiums are broadly similar; not harmful at market level at current practice. Firms must show how the arrangement supports fair value
Unnecessary switching after the clawback or indemnity periodAround 19,000 customers a year may be affected, roughly 0.1% of policyholders; market-wide intervention deprioritised, with action against individual firms instead
Broad new rulesRemedies go through existing frameworks; supervisory or enforcement action where firms fall short

What the FCA will do

  1. Work with partners to introduce protection prompts at key life events, such as buying a property and planning savings.
  2. Nudge consumers to use trusts and beneficiary nominations.
  3. Support a market-wide awareness campaign and an initiative to improve adviser confidence and consistency in discussing protection.
  4. Encourage innovation in underwriting and product design, including a TechSprint planned for Q3 2027 subject to interest.
  5. Bring stakeholders together to reduce delays in obtaining medical evidence.
  6. Run a webinar to address regulatory misconceptions.

Engagement with industry starts from October 2026, with FCA and industry-led work under way by the end of 2026. The FCA will monitor implementation and review progress.

What this means for protection advisers and brokers

Fair value evidence. The FCA reviewed firms' fair value assessments and found scope to strengthen the evidence on target market value and on how remuneration and distribution arrangements affect outcomes. Distributors should hold the insurer's fair value information, add their own remuneration and fees, and be able to show the total still represents fair value for the customers they serve.

Commission and switching. Indemnity commission and clawback periods remain lawful. A switch after the clawback period ends must be justified by the customer's needs or better value, documented in the file, and monitored in management information. Firms with switching rates that stand out will draw supervisory attention.

Panels. Restricted panels are permitted, but the firm must be able to explain why its panel delivers fair value and good outcomes for its target market.

Mortgage brokers. Property purchase is one of the life events where the FCA wants protection prompts. Brokers who do not discuss protection, or who refer it elsewhere, should record why, and those who do discuss it should be able to show customers understand what they are buying.

Vulnerable and complex needs. Customers with medical conditions or irregular incomes are the group most often left without cover. Firms should be able to show how their process and panel serve them, or where they signpost.

A checklist for the next 12 to 18 months

  • Refresh the fair value assessment for protection distribution, including remuneration
  • Add switching, lapse and replacement business to management information, with a review trigger
  • Document the panel rationale and test outcomes across it
  • Review the sales journey for drop-out points and unclear communications
  • Train advisers and brokers on raising protection at life events
  • Record protection discussions on mortgage and advice files
  • Include protection outcomes in the Consumer Duty annual board report

Our guides to Consumer Duty for insurance brokers and MGAs and broker remuneration and fair value cover the evidence the FCA expects. Firms starting out can read our guide to starting an insurance brokerage.

How Regulatory Counsel helps

We review protection fair value assessments, remuneration and switching controls, and build the Consumer Duty evidence advisers, brokers and insurers need. See our insurance, MGAs and brokers sector page.

References

This article is general information as at 15 November 2026 and is not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

When did the FCA publish the pure protection market study final report?

On 21 September 2026, as MS24/1.5. The study now moves into an implementation phase, with FCA and industry-led work under way by the end of 2026.

Is the FCA banning loaded premiums?

No. The FCA concluded that, at current levels, loaded premiums are not leading to poor pricing outcomes. Every firm must still be able to show its products provide fair value under PROD 4.

What is the protection gap?

The FCA found 58% of people hold no protection products, and 59% of those have never considered their protection needs. It wants more people to consider protection at key life events such as buying a home.

Will there be new rules for protection advisers?

No new rules are planned. The FCA will use existing frameworks, mainly the Consumer Duty and PROD 4, and take supervisory or enforcement action where firms fall short.

What did the FCA say about switching protection policies?

It found a risk that commission structures encourage unnecessary switching after the clawback period, affecting around 19,000 customers a year (roughly 0.1% of policyholders). It deprioritised market-wide intervention but will act against individual firms.

How quickly does the FCA expect progress?

The FCA expects meaningful progress within the next 12 to 18 months and will monitor implementation and review progress regularly.

Related